[ Post New Message | Post Reply to this One | Send Private Email to John Hicks | Help ]

Response to 'newbie' question--what film best for 800ISO, grain, sharpness, tonality

from John Hicks (jbh@magicnet.net)
In my experience with Rodinal 1:50 to 1:100 with various films, it usually results in 1/3 to a full stop less real speed than the ISO rating. That's why it may not be good for pushing; there's not much point in losing up to a stop in shadow density before you even get started.

PQ developers (Microphen etc) usually give up to 2/3 stop _increase_ in real speed for a normal CI...so it's as if you're getting something for nothing. Then you push (simply increasing contrast) from there.

So...based on the same CI...HP5+ in Microphen 1:1 or DD-X 1:9 gives a _full stop_ more real speed than in Rodinal w/sodium sulfite, or iow, EI 640 rather than EI 320. As you can see, if all you want is EI 800 you don't need to push much.

(posted 8715 days ago)

[ Previous | Next ]