1) renegade - beat em' up - ok(posted 8882 days ago)2) tempest - 3d shooter - control issues aren't THAT bad; i have a trackball and the game plays just fine. besides i voted it so i say keep it
3) moon patrol - horiz shooter - ok
4) new rally x - maze - though i didnt participate in T4, i can tell how much of you don't want this game due to rally x in T4, so its out
5) windjammers - sports - never played it but i guess its fine with me; ok
6) metal slug - horiz shooter/platformer - definitely ok, this game kicks too much ass :)
7) meikyu jima - puzzle? - man i love this game...if it's not in .35 maybe we can allow .36 just for this game? if so then another definite ok
8) elevator action - misc - no opinion yet; probably not ok because it was in deca2k; not entirely clear of genre
9) freeze - misc - never played it but i guess its ok
10) kangaroo - platform - ok i guess, out if conflicts with metal slug. consider possible leeching
11) the pit - never played it
12) vulgus - some kind of space shooter - ok
13) xybots - 3d shooter - conflicts with tempest; dont like this game too much anyway
14) twinkle star sprites - puzzle/shooter - seems unique enough and i love this game too; ok
15) teddyboy blues - platform - conflicts with metal slug and kangaroo
16) mikie - misc - no opinion, maybe ok
17) tag team wrestling - sports - conflicts with windjammers
18) asteroids deluxe - conflicts with vulgus, possible leeching
19) track & field - sports - i SO suck at this...conflicts with windjammers anyway
20) super cobra - shooter - conflicts with vulgus
21) ghosts & goblins - platform/shooter - just give me 1 reason why this should be included...it was in T3, way too easy to leech and conflicts with metal slug
22) wonderboy - platform - no opinion, i personally hate the controls when jumping, maybe out
23) metro cross - race - ok
24) ping pong - sports - conflicts with windjammers
25) rainbow islands - platform - dammit, conflicts with metal slug :( i like both games but metal slug showed up 1st - i hate to say this but its out
26) dk jr. - platform - conflicts with metal slug
27) super basketball - sports - conflicts with windjammers
28) tiger heli - vert shooter - damn vulgus...out
29) sega tetris - puzzle - conflicts with meikyu jima and partially with twinkle star sprites; atari version is far superior anyway
30) time pilot 84 - shooter - conflicts with vulgus
---
games ok'ed are: renegade, tempest, moon patrol, windjammers, metal slug, freeze, vulgus, twinkle star sprites, metro cross
games maybed are: kangaroo (this isn't a shooter/platform so i guess keep it), mikie (it seems unique enough though)
windjammers is actually in a grey area for me - if the scoring is too low (which means lots of ties) then replace with tag team wrestling