Ilford Pan F Plus in Rodinal

I shoot 2 1/4 B&W almost exclusively for outdoor natural light landscapes. I initially began with Tmax 100 but was not entirely satisfied with what I perceived as a subtle lack of sharpness or edge clarity in the finished print. (No, this is not a case of camera shake or enlarger misalignment or negative popping). The film just seemed to lack accutance, although the shadow detail and tonality is superior to any film I have ever used. It also resists blocking in the highlights very well. Grain is superb. However, that being said I was still not happy with the sharpness, and so tried Ilford Pan F Plus. I find this film excellent in regards to it's sharpness. I have to expose at an E.I. 25 to get adequate shadow detail however. Besides the 2 stop difference between it and Tmax 100, Pan F Plus is somewhat more contrasty. I develop in ID-11 1+1 for 8 1/2 minutes at 68 degrees. Recently I read of someone getting superb results with Pan F Plus and Rodinal 1+50. There is no tech data from Ilford at this dilution and an E.I. 25. Does anyone have any experience with this combination? My experience with Rodinal is somewhat limited, I recall it giving a "thinner" negative than what I am used to printing with my cold light enlarger and the grain appeared somewhat more distinct. Is this the general impression others have found?

[ Previous | Next ]