James and Daniel,(posted 9032 days ago)Must we bicker and argue. From the way I read it, Daniel was just giving us information he found in his experiment (and ALL experiments are valuable). I did not see him trying to convince me one way or the other. Yes you are right James, his experiment was flawed in many aspects and I would never use his finding to govern my photography. On the otherhand, don't you ever just wanna know what will happen if you do x to y? That's half the fun of darkroom work. Everything doesn't always have to be scientifically sound, as James warns, as long as you don't take your data and live by it. Good luck to both of you in your photographic ventures.