[ Post New Message | Post Reply to this One | Send Private Email to Charlie Strack | Help ]

Response to Tri-X or Tmax for beginning photo students?

from Charlie Strack (charlie_strack@sti.com)
I disagree with Peter's last post.

1. TMax films seem more "jumpy" to me and many others, that is they lack a smooth tonal scale. This is caused by their high micro- contrast. There is, however, no question that they provide a finer grain pattern.

2. TMax films require greater development care. The provide a bigger density change than traditional emulsions for a given change in development time (as a % of normal).Not only is this clearly documented in the magazine articles over the past decade, Kodak claims it was a design goal. In any case, the shape of the T-grain easily explains this phenomenon.

My point is that is faster and easier for a student just learning photographic processes to start getting decent results with the traditional film. The sooner this happens, the greater the chances of continuing their photographic endeavors.

(posted 8837 days ago)

[ Previous | Next ]