Who can you believe... who can you not believe?

Diane

SEPTEMBER 13, 1999

Y2K global warning

Russia, China, Japan, Italy top list of countries to watch

BY BOB BREWIN (antenna@fcw.com)
BY ORLANDO De BRUCE (orlando_debruce@fcw.com)
BY COLLEEN O'HARA (ohara@fcw.com)
IDG News Service

http://www.fcw.com/pubs/fcw/1999/0913/fcw-newsworldy2k-09-13-99.html

[Fair Use: For Educational/Research Purposes Only]

International travelers venturing abroad to celebrate the millennium should be aware that Russia, China, Japan and Italy top a list of countries that the State Department views as vulnerable to widespread failures because of the Year 2000 problem, according to department sources.

The State list, expected to be released Sept. 14, identifies 53 countries that could experience "unstable conditions" in their critical infrastructure systems -- such as telecommunications, power and water -- as a result of undiscovered or not yet remedied bad date code. Bad date code does not recognize four-digit years in computers. The list is expected to provide a detailed examination of Year 2000 problems in those countries, with air traffic control systems a key concern.

The Federal Aviation Administration has identified 35 countries that have not provided adequate information on their efforts to resolve Year 2000 problems in systems critical to air traffic control.

State will issue what it calls "consular information sheets" addressing Year 2000 problems in those countries.

Although not as strong as official Travel Warnings -- which recommend Americans avoid travel to certain countries -- the information sheets are intended to focus on areas of concern to the prudent traveler. The documents are available on the World Web at

http://www.travel.state.gov/travel_warnings.html

State's Web site said "if an unstable condition exists in a country that is not severe enough to warrant a travel warning, a description of the condition(s) may be included under an optional section titled 'areas of instability' " in the sheets.

A State spokesman said it is premature to determine if any country will elevate to the agency's travel warning category.

The American Society of Travel Agents considers these information sheets required reading for its members and international travelers, according to spokesman James Ashurst. These information sheets and Travel Warnings "are the first place we send consumers planning a trip...because State is in the business of protecting Americans abroad," Ashurst said.

The FAA drew up its list of 35 countries -- including Russia -- based on data provided by the International Civil Aviation Organization. Those countries failed to meet a July 31 deadline for reporting on the Year 2000 readiness of their airport and airline computer systems.

ICAO, whose membership includes 185 countries, had delayed release of that report indefinitely. Kenneth Mead, inspector general of the Transportation Department, said "time is running out" for the countries that have not responded to the survey. Uncertainties raised by this lack of responsiveness need to be resolved within a month as people start to lock in their travel plans, Mead said.

Airlines have concerns not only about air traffic control systems but also about the power and telecommunications systems essential to the operation of air traffic control systems. Asian airlines are so concerned about the cascading impact of Year 2000 on infrastructure and air traffic control systems that they have decided to reroute traffic around Indian airspace on routes from Asia to Europe.

According to IDG News Service, Singapore Airlines pilots plan a "sick out" during New Year's -- if necessary -- to avoid problems. United Airlines is working with domestic and international organizations to gather information on the Year 2000 status of countries' air traffic control systems, according to a United spokesman. "Right now, we plan to operate our entire schedule, [but] we'll only fly if we can do so safely," the spokesman said.

Sen. Robert Bennett (R-Utah), chairman of the Senate Special Committee on the Year 2000 Technology Problem, views the State list as essential not only to millennium travel plans, but also to national defense and economic health.

"It isn't usually polite to point out when your neighbor's lawn needs mowing," Bennet said, "[but] it is very important to point out which of our neighbors in the international community is falling behind with regard to Y2K preparedness. With the hopes of preventing international Y2K disasters from washing up on our shores, we will be looking at the State Department's country assessments from a number of different angles."

The State advisory also could affect efforts by the Pentagon to respond to an urgent request from Russia to help resolve potential Year 2000 disruptions to both its nuclear command and control systems and the electronic systems that safeguard its nuclear warhead stockpiles, according to an official of a U.S. defense contractor that has worked in the former Soviet Union for the past several years.

Any Year 2000 contracting teams sent to Russia from the United States will need to be out of Russia "well before" the new year, the official said.

DOD, which has considerable resources to help battle any Year 2000 infrastructure disruptions -- including redundant mobile communications systems, generators and water purification systems -- intends to husband those resources at its U.S. and foreign bases.

Top Priority

According to a message obtained by FCW from the Pentagon Joint Staff, it is the Pentagon's policy that, as a basic principle, "commanders cannot compromise operational readiness in providing support to civil authorities....All requests for assistance will be made within [State] channels rather...than to a local commander. Be prepared to redirect any requests for resources into proper channels.''

Reports that State is about to release a report putting Italy on a travel advisory list have caught Italian aviation officials off-guard. Italy expects millions of tourists to flock to the Vatican for the New Year's celebration. "I am highly surprised," said Pierluigi D'Aloia, president of the Italian air traffic control organization, Ente Nazionale Assistenza al Volo (ENVA).

Though he had no knowledge of any report by State, D'Aloia was quick to point out that recent visits from officials from the U.S. Embassy and State Department had led him to believe the United States had confidence in Italy's aviation-related Year 2000 plans. According to D'Aloia, his office had met with U.S. officials six months ago and as recently as last week.

Two lawyers sent by the U.S. Senate six months ago had been "highly satisfied" that the Italian government had met standards set by the International Air Transport Association (IATA). "They are either very good actors or liars," said D'Aloia, who was not able to supply the names of the U.S. officials.

Both ICAO and Aeronautical Information Circular requested Year 2000 compliance reports by July 1, 1999, outlining readiness, "and we did it," D'Aloia said. ENVA is confidently expecting a visit from IATA officials in October, D'Aloia said. "By October, Italy will be in condition and performing at 100 percent of our capacity," he added.

More Shrugs

Japanese government officials were surprised and then dismissive on hearing that Japan may top a list of countries with potentially dangerous Year 2000 problems.

"I don't understand what the State Department is talking about," said Mitsuo Hayasaka, the deputy director of the International Air Transport Bureau in Japan's Ministry of Transport. "On Aug. 25, the Air Transport Association tested flight-control systems in Japan and confirmed that the measures taken to solve the Year 2000 problem had been successfully completed." The ATA is the U.S. airline industry's trade association.

Hayasaka went on to say that on Sept. 16, the final test of Japan and Korea's Aeronautical Fixed Telecommunications Network system would be conducted and that previous tests have showed that the network is secure.

Also, Japan's domestic air system will undergo a full simulation of the rollover to 2000 tonight, Hayasaka said. He said no problems were anticipated.

Other officials had similar reactions.

"I can't understand it," said Motoyuki Ishize, deputy director of the Year 2000 Office for Japan's Cabinet Secretariat, pointing out that a July report from the State Department described Japan as a "no risk" country. "We can't comment until we see the report," he added.

Laura Rohde, at IDG News Service London bureau, filed reports on Italian reaction to the State Department moves and Michael Drexler, reported from the IDG News Service Tokyo bureau.

-- Diane J. Squire (sacredspaces@yahoo.com), September 13, 1999

Answers

Diane

Interesting article. I forwarded it to some of my Canadian contacts. We just love to escape the great white during the winter. :o)

-- Brian (imager@home.com), September 13, 1999.

But it should only be down for 2-3 days. Right?

Good dig Diane. You highlighted the right paras.

-- BB (peace2u@bellatlantic.net), September 13, 1999.

Looking forward to the State Department posts tomorrow. Should be an "interesting" read.

(And people are drinking oblivion juice if they don't think this isn't going to impact our domestic economy!) Diane

-- Diane J. Squire (sacredspaces@yahoo.com), September 13, 1999.

Thanks for another good catch and heads up Diane. Tomorrow is already shaping up to be 'one of those days'.

-- Rob Michaels (sonofdust@com.net), September 13, 1999.

F.Y.I. ...

SEPTEMBER 14, 1999 . . . 18:45 EDT
Critics: U.S. Y2K travel reports lack detail
(Federal Computer Week)
BY L. SCOTT TILLETT (scott_tillett@fcw.com)

http://www.fcw.com/pubs/fcw/1999/0913/web-state-09-14- 99.html

[Fair Use: For Educational/Research Purposes Only]

State Department officials today released a series of reports that outline for worldwide travelers potential Year 2000 problems in foreign nations, but critics say the reports lack detail.

The reports -- included in a set of revised "consular information sheets," which offer international travelers advice on everything from a country's road conditions to its crime activity -- cover more than 100 nations.

But at a press briefing today, State Department officials refused to single out any nation or set of nations as being the most at risk for Year 2000 problems. "We don't feel we should do an analysis between country and country," said Kevin Herbert, managing director for Overseas Citizens Services within the Bureau of Consular Affairs. "Do read these and make your own conclusions."

The newly revised consular information sheets were not made available to reporters until after the State Department press briefing today, preventing reporters from asking detailed questions about the Year 2000 reports. None of the reports, however, issues a travel warning for U.S. citizens to avoid a nation because of Year 2000 problems.

Federal Computer Week reported on Monday that Russia, China, Japan and Italy were expected to be among the countries viewed in the consular information sheets as being most vulnerable to widespread Year 2000 failures. The reports point out the potential for Year 2000 problems in those countries and many others.

For example, in the newly released consular sheet for Russia, department officials write, "Although Russia continues remediation efforts and contingency planning, at the present time, Y2K disruptions are likely to occur in the key sectors of electrical power, heat, telecommunications, transportation, and financial and emergency services."

But the reports lack needed information, said Sen. Robert Bennett (R- Utah), chairman of the Senate Special Committee on the Year 2000 Technology Problem. "The State Department report barely scratches the surface of serious Y2K problems facing many countries around the world," Bennett said in a prepared statement. "The report contains boilerplate language, making it difficult to discern the difference in Y2K readiness between well-prepared and unprepared countries. For example, one can discern little difference between China and Mexico, which are widely believed to be at opposite ends of the preparedness spectrum."

Herbert said U.S. missions abroad have been gathering Year 2000 information on host countries since the beginning of the year, twice offering each host country a chance to comment on the Year 2000 information that the State Department planned to include in the updated consular information sheets. "Getting to this point has been a lengthy process, required a lot of work on a lot of people's part," Herbert said.

-- Diane J. Squire (sacredspaces@yahoo.com), September 15, 1999.

I heard this State report on NPR. They read it like it was the gospel. It sounded tame to me. I thought to myself, nobody is going to prepare listening to this. They might not travel, but they'll think they're safe.

The people aren't being told the truth. Bennett ought to be ashamed of himself, saying it barely scratches the surface, and yet his warnings to the American people barely scratches the surface.

-- BB (peace2u@bellatlantic.net), September 15, 1999.

Yep, BB. It's all semantics.

Diane

See also...

Would you like to see the Y2K Information that the State Department compiled all on one page?

http://www.greenspun.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id= 001PX4

U.S. warns travelers on world Y2K problems (Links to State site)

http://www.greenspun.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id= 001PHf

-- Diane J. Squire (sacredspaces@yahoo.com), September 15, 1999.

A few more tidbits...

USIS Washington File
14 September 1999

State Department Releases 196 Y2K Readiness Reports

(No travel warning issued for Y2K deficiencies) (690)
By Phillip Kurata
USIA Staff Writer

[If this isnt Diplo-speak I dont know what is!]

Washington -- The U.S. State Department says anticipated computer problems related to the year 2000 (Y2K) date change are not serious enough to warrant travel warnings anywhere in the world.

"At this point, there is no indication for any country in the world that leads us to put out a travel warning," said Kevin Herbert, managing director of overseas citizens' services in the State Department's bureau of consular affairs.

More...

http://www.usia.gov/cgi-bin/washfile/display.pl?p=/products/washfile/ latest&f=99091405.clt&t=/products/washfile/newsitem.shtml

-- Diane J. Squire (sacredspaces@yahoo.com), September 15, 1999.