Congress' quick fix for labor shortage fails to tackle fundamental problems : LUSENET : Grassroots Information Coordination Center (GICC) : One Thread

Congress' quick fix for labor shortage fails to tackle fundamental problems

While the H-1B visa has brought talented, educated workers to Silicon Valley, its impact on American and permanent-resident computer programmers is a contentious issue



When Congress last month nearly doubled the number of H-1B visas for temporary foreign workers for the next three years, Silicon Valley's high-tech companies cheered. But the lawmakers' quick fix did nothing to tackle the fraud and abuse that plague the program and little to prevent backlogs that leave workers and companies in limbo. Congress ``didn't belly up to the board this time,'' said B. Lindsay Lowell of the Georgetown University Institute for the Study of International Migration in Washington, D.C., who recently completed a study of the H-1B, which has brought in nearly 300,000 high-tech workers since 1992.

Instead of just increasing the number of temporary workers who ``have limited rights and can be deported at a whim,'' Lowell said, Congress should have overhauled the system for giving H-1B workers green cards, which grant permanent residency. ``What they've done will exacerbate an existing problem.''

Foreign workers form network to lobby Congress for relief In a meeting hall in Sunnyvale early this summer, about 50 high-tech workers on H-1B visas listened to an Indian software engineer explain why they had gathered: green cards and red tape. It was the beginning of Silicon Valley's part in a short, furious, lobbying campaign by the Immigrants Support Network, a grass-roots organization of H-1B programmers that now claims a national membership of 15,000. The network came out of nowhere this year to blitz Congress for relief for H-1B workers, whom it described as ``indentured servants'' and slaves of the backlogged green-card process. The campaign ended in October when Congress passed legislation that should make it easier for H-1B workers to become permanent U.S. residents.

Murali Krishna Devarakonda, the 33-year-old software engineer, defined the problem: The H-1B visa was good only for six years, and it was taking at least that long for the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service to process applications for green cards.

Many people raised their hands when Devarakonda asked how many were soon going to have to leave the United States before they received their green cards.

``The green card is like an hourglass filling up, and the H1-B is a clock running fast,'' Devarakonda said. ``You get laid off, turn the hourglass over and start again. If your company is in trouble, even though you are the hotshot, you still get laid off because you are here on an H-1B. Is this what we deserve?''

``No!'' the crowd of H-1B workers cried.

By early October, the organization was counting its successes. Congress not only raised the cap on visas, it also broadened its legislation to include various revisions that should make it easier for H-1B workers to change employers and apply for green cards.

``It's a good time to celebrate,'' Devarakonda said Oct. 4, after Congress passed the legislation.

The network intends to monitor the INS to make sure it implements the new regulations, he said. It will follow issues that are still unresolved concerning spouses of H-1B workers and workers who are not pursuing green cards.

In the long run, the group wants H-1B tech workers to become automatically eligible for green cards after three years.

At the moment, though, the group has raised only about $73,000 from 986 members to pay for its lobbying campaign.

The Immigrants Support Network has a Web site at

- Pete Carey Whether shortage exists, workforce is turning global Independent studies have been unable to find conclusive evidence of a U.S. shortage of IT workers, something the Information Technology Association of America has insisted is the case since 1997. A Commerce Department study the same year projected a need for 1 million new information technology workers by 2005. The National Academy of Sciences, the General Accounting Office of Congress, the Congressional Research Service and the Computing Research Association each have observed that the problem possibly is caused by a short-term spike in demand or some other temporary market disequilibrium.

The NAS, which issued a report on the IT workforce in mid-October, noted that ""shortage'' is an emotionally loaded term and people don't agree on what it means.

Harris Miller, president of the ITAA, says he doesn't care what it's called. His membership, which includes 26,000 high-tech manufacturers and recruitment companies that hire out H-1B workers on contract, can't fill empty programming jobs.

But unemployment rates for high-technology professionals don't stand out in the current superheated economy, the Congressional Research Service noted in May. The ITAA regards job vacancy rates as a reflection of demand, but the CRS said those rates are an ""insufficient'' measure of labor shortage.

Furthermore, said ŠPeter Cappelli, an economist at the ŠWharton School of Management and the University of Pennsylvania who recently published a study on the IT worker shortage, ""it appears now that people are pouring into IT programs. The usual meaning of the word "shortage' doesn't seem to apply here.''

""There's a phenomenal number of people quitting IT every year,'' he said, citing a Labor Department statistic that there are as many people quitting IT jobs each year as there are new jobs available.

If older workers were retrained, much of the perceived shortage might be eliminated, Cappelli said.

Whether or not the shortage exists, ""employers want to hire from a global marketplace,'' said ŠPaul Donnelly, a consultant to the ŠInstitute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.

India has become a major provider because it has six rigorous institutes of technology, with degrees comparable to those from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology or Stanford University. Many other Indian universities also graduate skilled computer workers.

Pramod Mahajan, India's minister for information technology, observed during a visit to Silicon Valley in May, that there are plenty of Indian technologists to go around.

""We have enough to supply the world demand, which was created in the last couple of years, and still have domestic supply intact,'' he said. ""For the government of America, for industry, it is for them to judge whether Indian Americans contribute to the economy or whether they don't contribute to the economy, whether they create jobs or whether they take the jobs.''


Congress' quick fix for labor shortage fails to tackle fundamental problems Middlemen thriving in lucrative industry while foreign workers complain of abuse Demand for H-1B visas spawns fraud, abuse in India Under pressure from the tech industry, Congress raised the limit on H-1B visas to 195,000 per year from 115,000. But Mercury News reporting nationwide and in India found that underlying vulnerabilities remain:

Some U.S. labor contractors intimidate and underpay H-1B workers, yet the Department of Labor lacks broad investigative powers. The Department of Labor has recovered more than $1 million in back wages due more than 300 information technology workers. Officials say they could do more if they could subpoena business records and respond to leads beyond workers' complaints.

H-1B visa fraud is not uncommon, ranging from academic degrees faked overseas to phony job offers in the United States. The Immigration and Naturalization Service has only 40 staffers at its service centers nationwide to investigate fraud in H-1B and all other visa applications.

INS processing of H-1B visas has repeatedly stalled under months-long backlogs, causing uncertainty and disruption for workers, their families and companies. By raising the cap, the INS will have tens of thousands more applications to process, and officials say that, at best, the backlogs will run into next year. Although the new legislation raises fees, that won't be enough to upgrade systems, including a computer system so outmoded that the agency literally lost count and issued an extra 20,000 visas by mistake last year.

The H-1B visa program is no longer working the way it was supposed to, and the green-card system is breaking down. The H-1B was created to help companies cope with periodic shortages of labor by temporarily hiring experts from abroad for specific jobs that couldn't be filled locally. In fact, many companies now rely on the H-1B as a way to assure a pool of available, flexible, and often cheaper workers. And workers use it as a circuitous route to a green card. ``If we could get the immigration service to function, a lot of pressure would come off the H-1B program,'' said Rep. Zoe Lofgren, D-San Jose, a member of the House immigration subcommittee and a leader of the drive to increase the H-1B visa cap. H-1Bs have become valley mainstay With the H-1B, Congress in 1990 updated a previous temporary work visa by adding a time limit and a cap on the number of visas issued each year, and no longer requiring that visa holders promise not to try to stay permanently. Today, industry likes the visa because it solves short-term hiring difficulties, and foreign workers love it because of its promise of U.S. citizenship.

Proud of their contribution to the high-tech boom and the strength of the U.S. economy, H-1B workers have become a fixture in many Silicon Valley workplaces. Possibly 100,000 H-1B workers live in Northern California today, putting in the long hours demanded by the high-tech industry's hectic pace, and even going on to found or co-found major companies. About 420,000 H-1B workers are in the United States now, as many as half of them computer specialists, according to the Georgetown study.

Nearly half the top 100 companies that used the most H-1Bs in 1998 were based in California and New Jersey, with 14 percent based in San Jose, according to another Georgetown study. Four-fifths of the top companies were in the information technology business.

Some of the most sought after H-1B workers are employed directly by large U.S. companies, such as Silicon Valley's Cisco Systems and Oracle, which make them permanent employees. Others are hired by recruiting firms -- middlemen -- that bring in software specialists from India, China, South Africa and Europe, and then hire them out as temps to dot-com start-ups or banks and other businesses that need workers for software design or back-office operations.

By raising the cap and eliminating some red tape in October, Congress thrilled many immigration lawyers, industry leaders and foreign workers. ``I'm very, very happy about this bill,'' said Anu Gupta, a Fremont immigration lawyer. ``It's not going to solve all the problems overnight, but does go a long way.''

The new legislation changes some requirements that workers and companies found onerous. Many workers had complained that H-1B regulations resulted in a kind of indentured servitude in which workers were tied to their original employer by their visas and green-card applications, unable to complain or leave for a better job because their visas were at risk.

Under the new rules, an H-1B worker can move to a new job as soon as his or her new employer applies for a new H-1B, rather than waiting months until the application is approved. Green-card applicants in the final stages of the process also can switch employers without having to start their application over again. While they wait, they can apply for year-by-year extensions of their H-1Bs when they expire at the end of six years, instead of having to leave the country. And green-card processing should be faster because Congress also made available more cards to the countries with the highest demand, currently India and China.

Less red tape, but problems remainThe new rules should help companies like Intel Corp., which testified at a hearing this year that it had spent $200,000 moving a valuable H-1B worker to Malaysia after his visa expired.

They should also help H-1B workers like Asif Siddique, who spent much of this year holed up in his apartment, not working, while he and his wife waited to find out if his green card was approved or if he would have to leave the country.

By enabling workers to switch employers without delay, the new rules respond to complaints that H-1B workers are ``indentured.'' But even if the new law is put into effect quickly and efficiently, -- which previous revisions have not been -- it is still the employer that sponsors the green cards, which can take three to four years to obtain. And it will be the employer that files for the one-year H-1B extensions in the meantime.

And even for workers who don't seek green cards, it is risky to change employers: If a worker switches jobs as soon as his new employer files for a new H-1B visa, he takes a chance that the new visa won't come through. If it doesn't, the worker has to leave the country.

``The umbilical cord is still there,'' said Murali Krishna Devarakonda, a founder of the Bay Area chapter of Immigrants Support Network, which lobbied Congress for changes to the visa.

That means workers still can be intimidated by unscrupulous middlemen. The new legislation fails to bolster enforcement of laws against exploiting and underpaying foreign workers while they are here. An employment lawyer in San Jose, Phil Griego, said he has received increasing numbers of complaints from H-1B workers about employers for the past six months.

``You can't go after these employers because they are just mom-and-pop operations, and they close up and disappear,'' he said.

Bruce Burns is a San Jose immigration lawyer who has received a couple of dozen complaints from foreign temps in the past 18 months about middlemen that were keeping up to half the worker's promised prevailing wage. The new legislation will help H-1B workers switch jobs more freely, but some workers will still have to contend with contracts that force them to pay $10,000 to $30,000 in ``liquidated damages'' for leaving.

``To say you have to pay something equivalent to several months to a third of your year's salary is unconscionable,'' Burns said.

Visa fraud merits little attention Another problem is visa fraud, which starts abroad and in Silicon Valley. Phony résumés are a common sight at U.S. consular offices overseas. According to the State Department, one-fifth of the H-1B applications received in India last year contained fraudulent information, this year, 11 percent.

In the United States, the INS tries to identify companies that use the H-1B in illegal immigration scams or that charge H-1B workers exorbitant fees for bringing them here and then leaving them stranded, with no jobs.

``I had one relative come; he's working in a pizza shop,'' said one East Coast programmer and critic of the H-1B. ``He came on an H-1B, with falsified papers.''

But the ability of the INS to detect and prevent fraud is limited and won't improve with the added workload that comes with the higher cap on H-1Bs. Visa applications of all types exceed 4 million each year, and the INS requires its workers to process a certain number of H-1Bs every day, said Jimmie Ward, assistant director for operations at the INS California center. When it comes to spotting phony middlemen, he said, ``It's like the finger in the dike. We try to identify as much as we can.''

Résumé padding also occurs in the United States, effectively subverting the intent of the H-1B program.

Three former executives of an Indian-run labor contractor said their boss automatically added two years of experience and phony skills to the résumés of its hundreds of H-1B employees as soon as they arrived in the United States in order to charge companies an additional $30 to $40 an hour.

``Fortunately, they are very bright people and in general are capable of faking it out in the field, and eventually they become very good workers,'' said one former executive, who asked not to be identified. ``But it is straight-out fraud against the customers, and it gives the industry a bad name.''

Ward, of the INS, said he has heard of such cases but has not received complaints.

New rules increase work for INS Visa processing is also overloaded, and some INS officials are upset that more work is coming their way. In addition to the near doubling in the number of H-1Bs available for the next three years, another 30,000 to 50,000 applicants who didn't get visas last year because the cap was reached in March will receive them right away. Thousands of additional family members will come along each year as will H-1B visas sought by universities and non-profit organizations, which will no longer be counted within the cap.

Congress created a new account to pay for reducing the backlog, but has yet to fund it. To pay for the increased workload, Congress raised the application fee to $1,000 from $500 and allotted the INS and Labor Department each 4 percent of the fee rather than the current 1.5 percent. But that additional $32.50 per application in fees will barely pay salaries for more staff.

To handle the added work, the INS will also need to hire and train new employees, add new offices and retool its computer systems. The fee increase ``is not going to help with the dramatic improvements in systems and technology that are needed,'' said William Yates, head of the Immigration Service Division of the INS.

An increase in green-card applications has also swamped the Labor Department. A department official said that since 1998 it has been receiving tens of thousands more applications for work certifications, the first step in getting an employment-based green card.

INS and Labor Department backlogs aren't just a matter of paperwork. They take an enormous toll on temporary workers and their families because they prolong the uncertain wait for a green card.

Cry for help ``Please help me,'' wrote Benedict Teck-Choy Chong, 37, of San Jose in an affidavit accompanying a lawsuit filed this year against the INS for delays in processing green cards.

``There is a terrible uncertainty about holding on to a job in an economic climate in which companies can crash overnight or be bought with unprofitable divisions pruned away,'' he explained. Chong got his green card and dropped the lawsuit.

The rising tide of visas, applications for green cards and other paperwork has swamped the INS, especially during peak periods.

``We have files everywhere,'' said a staff member at one of the busiest of the four INS centers during a heavy backlog earlier this year. ``In trailers, warehouses, in storage places, we have them in the aisles, four high, throughout the whole building.

``I was going into the bathroom the other day, and there were files lined up on the wall by the restroom. I opened the door, and I heard a girl say to another, `Hey, Mildred, here's that box from Portland we were looking for.' ''

The INS service center in Laguna Niguel at times this year was the most overworked in the country. With the increased cap, ``backlogs are going to build up immediately,'' Ward said. ``Everyone's going to be complaining again.''

While the H-1B has brought talented, educated people to Silicon Valley, its impact on American and permanent-resident computer programmers is a contentious issue.

Cutting corners Labor officials say some companies use the H-1B, a specialty worker visa, to bring in run-of-the-mill programmers who will work for less than a fair wage.

``Most of them have less than a master's degree,'' said Peggy Taylor, legislative director of the AFL-CIO office in Washington, D.C., citing an INS survey. ``Well, what are you using these visas for?''

Many jobs don't require the advanced skills of a computer science graduate, several studies have found.

Some companies and universities are trying to help train workers locally for such jobs. Cisco Systems is underwriting a series of two-year courses in networking, now taught at 4,000 schools in 80 countries. George Mason University in Virginia offers courses to non-computer science students for jobs in information technology.

``You don't want your help desk being manned by a computer science graduate,'' said William Aspray, executive director of the Computing Research Association.

Retraining for older high-tech workers could also be a way to fill some of these and more advanced programming jobs. Retraining is fundamental to the industry, but most companies would rather hire up-to-date temps from abroad than take on the considerable expense of retraining, programmers say.

``Half of what you know becomes obsolete every 36 months in a technology market,'' said Dominique Black, head of a personnel placement firm in Redwood City. ``That means you need to be significantly retraining about 20 percent of your time.''

Some high-tech employers say they don't see many older unemployed American programmers looking for permanent jobs.

``In Silicon Valley, anyone out there who's not on a visa -- hardware engineers, programmers -- is now going toward contract work and wants $150-plus an hour,'' said Margo Sanders earlier this year when she was corporate staffing manager for 3Com Corp. in Santa Clara. The H-1B engineer wants to become a permanent employee, she said.

But getting H-1B workers green cards is a big problem that will continue despite the new legislation.

``I don't think they seriously addressed the fact there's a real imbalance between the number of people they are letting in on H-1B visas and the number of people who are able to get green cards,'' said Carl Shusterman, a Los Angeles immigration lawyer.

If the past is a guide, at least half the H-1B workers will apply for green cards, some of them with spouses. That could burden the system with 160,000 green card requests each year, said Georgetown's Lowell. But the annual limit of green cards available for temporary workers of all kinds -- not just H-1Bs -- and their families, is just 140,000.

Some analysts say the H-1B needs to be redesigned into two kinds of work visas: one a short-term permit for specific projects and another that would lead directly to a green card in two or three years.

During the lobbying for the current legislation, high-tech companies set aside their desire for green-card reform for the more pragmatic goal of an increase in H-1Bs.

``We'd love to see the green-card process streamlined,'' said Mary Dee Beall, Hewlett-Packard's official in Washington, D.C., in charge of H-1B matters. ``Since HP's practice in hiring foreign workers is for them to become permanent residents, it would be manna from heaven if that would happen. But that would be a major reform of the immigration process.''

-- Martin Thompson (, November 21, 2000

Moderation questions? read the FAQ